|
|
POLITICS-IRAN: Corruption Eats Into Roots of Society
By Ramin Mostaghim
TEHRAN, July 15, 2004 (IPS) - Graft has become so widespread in Iran
that the government's anti-corruption efforts have been criticised as
being insufficient to stem the growing malaise in the country, which
many Iranians say is getting worse by the day.
''If I do not pay a 'success fee' for any contract I sign with
government organisations, big or small, I will be out of business
very quickly,'' Mahmoud Asgari, the proprietor of two medium-sized
printing houses in Tehran, told IPS.
''Our main revenue comes from publishing government brochures,
news bulletins, books and political campaign posters,'' he
continued. ''If these items end up in our printing machines, that
implies we have agreed to pay 'success fees' to these brokers or
middlemen, whose generic name in colloquial Farsi is 'kar chaq
kon.'
According to Asgari, ''success fees'' range from 10 to 30 percent of
the total value of a contract, which for him means he must pay
government officials as much as 600 U.S. dollars for a job.
The 55-year-old publisher said he has to make similar payments
whenever he applies for business loans.
''Every businessman, for every any single loan he receives from
the banks, is obliged to pay a fraction of the total amount (to bank
officials),'' Asgari said.
These kickbacks, he added, allow government bank managers to
live ''well off'' even though their official salary is only about 500 U.S.
dollars.
But the government readily acknowledges that corruption is a
serious problem.
Last month for example, the Intelligence Ministry announced that,
since it was created two years ago, its Anti-Economic Corruption
Department has filed 821 ''economic corruption dossiers'' involving
government officials to various courts.
While touring the annual exhibition of the Government Inspection
Organisation (GIO), another anti-corruption agency, the new speaker
of the parliament Gholamali Haddadadel told reporters, ''I am really
sorry to see such a huge rate of corruption in the country.''
His comments came in response to a briefing by GIO in which he
was told that two billion U.S. dollars had been wasted on a mining
project in northeastern Iran that was based on fraudulent feasibility
studies.
The GIO, part of the judiciary branch, held its first annual exhibition
three years ago, at a time when graft and other corruption among
government officials were widely viewed as running rampant.
This year's show was held late last month on the premises of the
newly built Mosalla - the capital's grand praying hall.
The annual exhibition is held to highlight the achievements of
GIO's nationwide anti-corruption campaign, but those whose job is
to carry out the campaign say it also underscores why the
government's efforts are largely ineffective.
''These weeks of attempts to do something (about corruption) are
official cliché,'' said Qolam Homayouni, who works as an economic
inspector for GIO.
He told IPS: ''The fight against corruption should be initiated from
the bottom and by genuine NGOs (non-governmental
organisations). And, the press must be free to scrutinise the
governmental entities.''
''It is naive for people to assume their government can have self-
cleaning power,'' Homayouni continued.
A guide at the exhibition, who spoke to IPS on the condition of
anonymity, pointed out, ''No commoners, no one from the
grassroots are here. Instead, high-ranking officials, top managers -
- of course, under police escort - are bused in to be briefed about
the anti-corruption campaign, and are given the understanding that
no single (act of) wrong doing is disregarded.''
This claim about the agency's thoroughness was disputed by the
guide - an economics expert who works as a rank-and-file member
a GIO investigative team.
He pointed out that the GIO has 988 experts and inspectors to
monitor more than 2.3 million full-time public servants and millions
of other people who earn a living ''selling their services to various
ministries under temporary contracts.''
''How on earth is it feasible to control everything and fight
widespread corruption?'' he asked.
He also wondered whether supreme leader Ayatollah Khameini
was sufficiently committed to fighting corruption, suggesting that,
like his pre-revolutionary predecessor the shah, he may use
knowledge of corruption among ''big fish'' to keep them in line.
''That is an effective way to maintain power and to guarantee no
mutiny among top officials,'' he said.
Former shah, Reza Pahlavi, lost power in 1978.
It was corruption and a crackdown on opposition voices during his
rule that caused Iran's constitutional monarchy to topple - allowing
conservative clerics to seize power and institute a hard-line Islamic
state.
Ahamad Bashiri, a 73-year-old attorney well-versed in the
government's anti-corruption efforts, said: ''This judiciary branch
which is supposed to fight corruption is deeply corrupted.''
Noting that the head of the judiciary's security and intelligence
department recently announced that more than 400 'kar chaq kon '
were detected in various courts last year, he asked, ''How can the
GIO, under the auspice of this kind of judiciary branch, successfully
fight corruption?''
Despite there being questionable effectiveness, the government's
anti-corruption efforts are widely publicised.
''Fighting financial corruption and what in the Islamic regime has
been coined as 'rantkhari' (rent-seeking) are highlighted on an
unprecedented scale these days,'' said Ali Sepidarkish, a retired
insurance manager.
''I am sure, if they are serious in fighting (corruption), it is due to
this feeling shared among officials that the survival of the whole
system is at stake,'' he told IPS. (END)
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
What is RSS?
